I’m sure you are as tired of Notorious’s fluff pieces as I am. Kid Rock and Fred Durst are both idiots and we didn’t need to waste web space to reaffirm that.
I’m The Rootless Cosmopolitan. I got sick of living in Connecticut, so I moved to Tucson, Arizona. When that got old I moved back to CT. When that bored me, I moved to Brooklyn, NY where I no reside. In this moment, I can safely say I’m never leaving. I’ve never felt more at home than in NY.
So why do you care? Oh right, because I’m a Jew and this gives you the right to question my loyalty to anything and everything. Rootless Cosmopolitan was a term used by Stalin and his anti-Semitic campaign. The Jews have no loyalty to any country in which they reside, thus they are not to be trusted. You’ll have to excuse us if we don’t have ties to places that treated us poorly or just threw us out after a few hundred years. This isn’t the first instance of this type of accusation. It had a similar place in the Dreyfus Affair and most recently, Rudy Giuliani used it against Barak Obama. Giuliani earns creativity points, but he’s not doing anything to dispell myth that Italian-Americans are all big dumb idiots (did I mention I’m one of those, too? Just in case you were beginning to trust me). The term has since been replaced by “zionist,” a since bastardized concept which I’ll touch on in a future post (don’t worry, you’ll be offended).
Yes, I moved to New York because I needed a little more action in my life. You’ve got me there. Does this make me rootless? I came back to the northeast after my stay in Tucson to be closer to family and friends, all based around the quaint suburban Connecticut town I grew up in. A town I both love and loathe, and don’t pretend you don’t feel the same way about your town. How’s that for roots?
So what if I’m a little cosmopolitan. You’ll have to excuse me if I don’t make enough money to afford a new car, so I move to a city where I don’t need one. I’m well aware that this green shit is all the rage these days, but you know damn well it’s practical, especially in NYC, and I’m a short train ride from the folks that brought me into this world. So what if I enjoy living in places where there is stuff to do all the time? So what if I enjoy living in places where I can actually find work that stimulates me? I’m just a selfish person I guess. No loyalty either.
I harbor no ill will towards my friends and family that have elected to stay in suburbia or in the towns where they grew up. I’m mostly happy that they’ve found a situation that works for them, but aren’t I entitled to figure out what works for me?
To be fair, moving to NY has just increased my own internal anti-Semitism. I’ve always had a disdain for Jews (and don’t call me a fucking “self-hating Jew,” whatever the fuck that means. I love Judaism and I love myself, both to an alarming extent) and it’s only increased with being in NY. Somewhere along the lines, people got the idea that simply living in NYC made you a better Jew. Way to back up the whole “cosmopolitan” thing folks. I’m sure it’s the same in Brookline or other excessively Jewy places.
What’s Jewy? It’s a way to describe folks on a scale, versus “Jewish” which is binary: you’re either Jewish or you’re not. None of this Half-Jewish crap. I only have one Jewish parent, but I’m Jewish. Only dumbass Americans would try to make some conceptual like national heritage into a pie chart. I would consider myself, pretty Jewy: I read too much leftist Jewish news, I try to incorporate traditions, practices, and thinking into my daily life. If Joe Doenstein doesn’t do anything to engage in Jewish life, it doesn’t make him any less Jewish, just less Jewy. And there’s nothing wrong with that. Sort of…
Guess what folks, if you’re going to be Jewish, you have to do something about it. I’m not going to be preachy here, I don’t care what you do about it, but you have to do something. It’s active. Not passive. Don’t give me that “I’m a cultural Jew” or “I’m a secular Jew” bullshit. Engage in the culture then. And recognize that the “culture” you’re choosing to identify with is a result of centuries of traditions and practices that descend from what it meant to be Jewish in past years. If you’re going to insist “I’m of Jewish descent,” and not do a damn thing about it, that’s fine. But if you must claim to be a Jew, you have a responsibility to do something. ANYTHING. Stop pretending it’s a fucking cool kids club with your little fucking membership card. I don’t care what camp you went to, what youth group you were in, or that your last name has a Germanic, Polish or Russian ending.
Oh, so you know a little Yiddish? Learn more than the derogatory terms for non-Jews (because saying “shiksa” and “goy” is no different from saying “nigger,” don’t kid yourself. Ignorance is not becoming on you). Learn the damn language. Love “Jewish” foods? Everyone does, but it’s not substance. Did you know most Jewish foods exist because of A. a ritual requirement or B. were really just absorbed from the surrounding cultures. Don’t you feel so Jewish now? Reinforcing negative stereotypes doesn’t make you a good Jew. Hurts to hear it, doesn’t it?
Guy who tells me snobbily that he’s “whole Jewish” after hearing of my mixed descent but then proceeds to refer to his girlfriend as a shiksa? You’re embarassing the Jews, putting your girlfriend down, and acting ignorant. Stop.
I remember a friend telling me about how proud he was to attend some [probably good-intentioned but pointless] Israeli pride parade in New York and snobbily remarking that “of course we’re on [this street], we own most of it!” You’re acting arrogant. If the basis of your Jewish pride is based on Jewish wealth and prosperity, than we need to have a talk about substance.
All of you, you’re just insulting yourself and pissing me off. Take a little responsibility for educating yourself. Please? For this angry Jew?